A plumber in Mississauga told me last spring that his phone had gone quiet. Not dead, just quieter than it should have been for the season. He was still ranking well on Google. His website looked fine. What he didn't know was that a growing number of his potential customers weren't searching on Google at all anymore. They were opening ChatGPT and typing something like: "My basement drain is backing up, what should I do first and when do I need a licensed plumber?" His name never came up.

That conversation stuck with me. Because the problem isn't rare. Across the small and mid-sized businesses I work with in Canada, I see the same blind spot: owners optimizing hard for Google while an entirely different stream of customer intent is flowing through AI tools they've never thought about.

The real question isn't whether to care about this. It's how to find those questions before your competitors do.

Why traditional keyword research misses AI queries entirely

The data gap no one talks about

Every keyword tool you've heard of — Google Keyword Planner, Ahrefs, SEMrush — measures one thing: how often people type a phrase into Google. That data is genuinely useful, and I'm not dismissing it. But it tells you nothing about what people type into ChatGPT, Copilot or Gemini, because those platforms don't publish query data. There is no database. The queries simply don't exist in any tool you can buy a subscription to.

This matters more than most owners realize. According to Think with Google, search behaviour has been fragmenting for years across platforms, and AI-powered tools have accelerated that fragmentation sharply since 2024. A customer researching a home renovation in Oakville today might ask Google "best kitchen contractor near me" and separately ask ChatGPT "what questions should I ask a kitchen contractor before signing anything?" Those are two different moments, two different intents, and only one of them shows up in your keyword report.

The nature of AI queries is different

People write differently when they talk to an AI. They use full sentences. They give context. They ask follow-up questions in the same session. Instead of "divorce lawyer Toronto cost," someone types "I'm going through a separation in Ontario and I'm worried about the cost of a lawyer. What should I budget and what does the process actually look like?"

That's not a keyword. It's a conversation. And if a family law firm in Toronto has a page on their site that answers that question directly and honestly, there's a real chance an AI tool cites it. If they don't, they're invisible to that person at the exact moment they're deciding whether to pick up the phone.

How to find the questions your customers actually ask AI

Use the AI as a research tool first

The most direct method I've found: open ChatGPT or Copilot, describe your business and your typical customer in plain language, and ask the AI what questions someone in that situation would type. Be specific. "I run a mid-sized accounting firm in Hamilton that works with construction contractors. What would one of my clients type into you when they're stressed about taxes or cash flow?"

The AI will generate a list. Some of it will be obvious. Some of it will surprise you. The surprises are what you're after. Write them all down, then run the exercise again from a different angle: "What would someone ask you before deciding whether to hire an accountant or handle it themselves?" That second framing often surfaces the objections and fears that your current website completely ignores.

Reddit is underrated, and I'll die on that hill

Reddit is one of the most honest records of what real people ask when they're confused, frustrated or trying to make a decision. For a Canadian SMB owner, the relevant subreddits depend on your sector, but r/PersonalFinanceCanada, r/legaladvicecanada, r/HomeImprovement, r/Entrepreneur and city-specific subreddits are worth an hour of your time every month.

Search your service category and read the posts from the last year. Look for the questions that get long, engaged threads. Those are the questions people can't easily find answers to elsewhere. Those are your content opportunities. They're also the questions AI tools struggle to answer well without citing a specific source, which means a good page from you stands a real chance of getting picked up.

Mine your own conversations

This one sounds obvious but almost nobody does it systematically. Every question a prospect asks you during a sales call, every objection a client raises, every confused email you get from someone who just signed on — those are gold. They're direct evidence of what your customers don't understand or can't find online.

I worked with a franchise network that had grown from 1 to 14 locations in three years. One of the first things we did before touching any content was go through six months of intake emails and call notes. The questions prospects were asking their local franchise owners were completely different from the keywords the network was targeting. The content strategy shifted, and so did the results: cost per new client dropped by more than half.

Google's "People Also Ask" still tells you something

It's not perfect, but Google's "People Also Ask" boxes reflect real queries that people type in full sentences. They're closer to AI query patterns than standard short-tail keywords. Search your main service on Google, expand every "People Also Ask" box you see, and note the questions that aren't answered anywhere on your site. Those gaps are exactly what AI tools fill for users — and if you answer them better than anyone else, you become the source the AI cites.

What to do once you have the questions

Answer directly, at the top, without preamble

The single biggest mistake I see on SMB websites: the answer to a customer's question is buried three paragraphs in, after a history of the company, a general description of the service, and a sentence about "our team of dedicated professionals." AI tools don't have patience for that, and neither do customers.

If someone asks "how much does a furnace replacement cost in Toronto," your page should open with a direct, honest range and the factors that affect it. Not a corporate preamble. The rest of the page can develop the nuance, the process, the trust signals. But the answer comes first. Google's own documentation on featured snippets has been saying this for years. The same logic now applies to AI citations.

One question, one page

There's a temptation to build a massive FAQ page that answers fifty questions at once. I understand the impulse. It feels efficient. It's usually a mistake. AI tools and search engines alike prefer pages that go deep on one topic rather than pages that skim across many. A page titled "Everything you need to know about commercial cleaning contracts in Ontario" will almost always outperform a generic FAQ, because it signals specific expertise on a specific question.

This is also a positioning decision. If you can't articulate clearly who you serve and what specific problem you solve better than anyone else, your content will be generic, and generic content doesn't get cited. Before you write a single page, the positioning has to be right. That's work that happens before execution, not alongside it. It's the part most owners skip because it feels abstract, but it's the part that determines whether any of the content work pays off.

Update what you have before adding more

Most SMB websites have three to ten pages that already rank for something, get some traffic, and then lose people because the content is thin or outdated. Before publishing new pages targeting AI queries, audit what you already have. A page that already has some authority and just needs a better direct answer at the top is a faster win than a brand-new page starting from zero.

This is the audit-first logic I apply with every client. You don't build on a foundation you haven't inspected. Our growth & operations audit does exactly this: we map what's already there, what's working, what's wasting budget, and where the fastest gains are before recommending anything new.

The positioning question underneath all of this

AI visibility is a symptom, not the disease

Here's my honest take: most of the SMB owners who are invisible to AI tools aren't invisible because they haven't optimized for AI. They're invisible because their positioning is vague. Their website says they offer "quality services" and "customer satisfaction." Their messaging could belong to any of their competitors. When an AI tool is trying to recommend a specific business for a specific need, vague positioning is disqualifying.

The businesses that show up in AI answers tend to have one thing in common: they've made a clear claim about who they serve and what they do differently. A commercial electrician in Brampton who has built content specifically for property managers dealing with aging electrical panels in multi-unit buildings will outperform a general electrician with a prettier website every single time. The specificity is the advantage.

Where to start if you're running a 10 to 50-person business without a marketing team

I'm not going to pretend this is a weekend project. Done properly, identifying the right questions, auditing your existing content, rewriting the pages that need it, and building new ones takes months of consistent work. The question isn't whether it's worth doing. It clearly is. The question is whether you have the internal capacity to do it while also running your business.

Most of the owners I work with don't. That's not a criticism; it's just the reality of running a company with 10 to 50 people and no dedicated marketing director. The answer isn't to hire a junior content writer and hope for the best. It's to have someone with strategic oversight making the positioning and prioritization decisions, and then executing against them consistently. That's the gap our strategy services are built to fill.

But even before any of that, you can start this week with one hour: open ChatGPT, describe your business and your best customer, and ask what that customer would type into the AI when they have the problem you solve. Write down everything that comes back. You'll probably find three or four questions your website doesn't answer at all. That's your list. That's where to start.

FAQ

How do I find the questions my customers ask AI tools like ChatGPT?

The most reliable method is to ask the AI directly: open ChatGPT or Copilot, describe your business and your typical customer, and ask what questions someone in that situation would type. Then cross-reference with Reddit threads, Google's "People Also Ask" boxes, and your own sales conversations. Traditional keyword tools won't show you these queries.

Why don't traditional keyword tools show AI search queries?

Tools like Google Keyword Planner measure Google search volume. AI tools like ChatGPT and Copilot don't report query data publicly. The questions people type into AI tend to be longer, more conversational and more specific than Google searches — they simply don't appear in any keyword database.

Does appearing in AI answers actually bring more customers to my business?

It depends on the context. For local and specialized services, AI tools increasingly recommend specific businesses when the business has clear, authoritative content online. If your website answers the exact question the AI user asked, you have a real chance of being cited. If your site is thin or generic, you won't be.

How much time does it take to build an AI-visible content strategy?

Identifying the right questions takes a few hours of structured research. Writing or updating content to answer them properly takes longer — typically several weeks of consistent work. The faster path is to audit what you already have, fix the gaps, and publish two or three strong pages before adding more.

What's the difference between optimizing for Google and optimizing for AI tools?

Google rewards pages that rank well across many related searches. AI tools look for pages that answer one specific question clearly and completely. The writing style is different: shorter paragraphs, direct answers at the top, no fluff. A page built for AI visibility often performs better on Google too, but the reverse isn't always true.